Pin It

March 26, 2017

1 Social Business Post – 3 Feet – 3 Boobs

By michaelpace on July 25, 2012

What the hell happened last Friday in the social business world? Did the planets align to erase the business brains of people at the customer facing keyboards of 3 disparate companies? Alien hackers took over twitter and customer relationship accounts? Or did 3 companies just get lazy while working in the connected world?

While I do think weirdness happens outside of our little world, my money is on the latter (laziness).

Story 1: How to shove your own foot up your ass

I originally heard the story from Social Media Explorer in a post called Customer Service Isn’t An Act. It’s a Trait. To make a (interesting) long story short, @solve360 chose to pick a fight on their social network instead of helping a customer, and possibly a future business partner. See below: Solve360 conversation with customers

For more details head to Megan’s Meanderings

Lessons Learned:

In my opinion, this is a company culture issue. From bottom to top, this company does not understand service (which doesn’t bode well for a Customer Relationship Management software company). They choose to see service as an unwelcomed cost of doing business, instead of looking at it as an opportunity to help a customer, build a relationship, move a challenger to a champion, or even just retain a current customer. While this may be random incident or everyone was having a case of the Mondays, but Solve360 may want to take a step back, get clear on their Values and decide if retention and loyalty are critical to a cloud or SAAS company (guess what – it is).

Story 2: How to shoot yourself in the foot

This Twitter post is from the NRA (National Rifle Association) the morning of the Aurora murders.

@NRA_Rifleman tweet

On the surface, it appears to be horribly disrespectful and frankly disgusting. The post was deleted from their Twitter stream not long after posting, but what happens on the internet stays on the internet. However, I believe there is more to this story. My assumption is this was a scheduled tweet, scheduled well before we learned of the events in Aurora.

Lessons Learned:

Scheduling tweets is a perfectly acceptable practice of social business. It allows you to create conversations off hours, reach different sets of audiences, and smooth out the workload for your conversation agents. Scheduling is a shortcut; shortcuts are needed. However, every shortcut comes at a risk (otherwise it would not be a shortcut). Like any other area of business, you need to understand your risks, determine what is acceptable, transferrable, or worth creating mitigation steps. In the NRA’s (controversial) line of business, it is sad to say that incidents like last Friday’s massacre can happen at any time. While I would not stop scheduling, I would ensure they have a crisis management plan in place, and understand their roles in executing.

On another note, I think they were smart in deleting the tweet, but they missed an equally important step, admitting to their mistake. As of this date, I have not seen an apology tweet or link (it doesn’t mean that it doesn’t exist). They may have even deleted the entire account name, as it is no longer exists on Twitter. A simple, accountable explanation with an apology and thoughts toward the impacted families/friends would have gone a long way.

Story 3: You Put Your Foot in My Mouth

By now many folks have heard and/or seen the @Celebboutique tweet from last Friday, only a mere few hours after the horrific tragedy in an Aurora, CO movie theater. I think the picture above speaks to the shear ignorance of person at the helm of their twitter account. I am not here to beat a dead horse; I am here to help with the lessons learned. @celebboutique tweet

Post the immediate public uproar, @Celebboutique tried to apologize. @celebboutique follow up










Lessons Learned:

It is clear that @Celebboutique outsources their twitter handle to an offshore PR agency. Outsourcing can be good; offshore outsourcing can be better. Outsourcing usually allows companies to move many overhead costs to parties who specialize in a specific operation, therefore opening up funds and/or space to move their business forward in other areas. I have a few rules of outsourcing effectively:
1. You never outsource your core competency or value proposition
2. Your relationship with your outsourcer needs to be ACTIVELY managed; it is not an “off the side of the desk” activity
3. Cultural compatibility is more important than all the money talk that follows in the selection process
4. Outsource customer facing solutions at your OWN RISK

Based on the follow up tweets from @Celebboutique, they did not heed to my rules of effective outsourcing.
Their last mistake in the myriad of mistakes was their placing blame on their foreign outsourcer. When I interact with a company, I see it as a single entity. For example, if I shop at Costco, I do not think about how it affects their supply chain department, marketing, or human resources; it is just Costco. As a consumer, I have enough brands occupying my attention; I don’t separate companies into divisions. Regardless, if @Celebboutique hit the enter key or not, it was their company’s mistake; own it.

About mpace101


  1. 2 Comments

    Totally agree. As someone who is just getting their feet wet as a social media professional, I take these as (convenient?) learning opportunities. I do feel lot of it is Social Media 101, especially the @CelebBoutique snafu, but nevertheless great things to be reminded of. I would like to know, any thoughts on the current implosion of Chik-Fil-A in social right now?


      Mary – thanks for the comment.
      On Chik-Fil-A, on one hand I feel bad for them and on the other they are getting what they deserve.
      I am sure the views on marriage of their CEO/President are not shared values of many in the company. However, their PR/Marketing Communications have to figure out how to move on from the current situation. Now, creating a fake Facebook account in order to respond to customer comments is the last thing they should do. The commentary has already broken a level of trust, they should have tried to identify ways to humanize the company as more than the thoughts of their CEO. The big lessons learned for companies is to have a plan for when crisis or when situations like this happen. It is also much bigger than social media teams.

  2. 2 Comments

Speak Your Mind